Apple‘s HomePod smart speakers offer remarkable sound quality and seamless integration into the Apple ecosystem. This post compares the first-generation HomePod, introduced in 2018 and now discontinued, with the second-generation HomePod released in 2023.
While the second-generation model boasts some improvements, the first-generation HomePod is still a viable option, especially for those looking to save on costs.
Key Differences:
The second-generation HomePod offers improvements over the first generation, including a processor upgrade from the A8 chip to the S7 chip, which enhances sound calibration. The exterior design also features a larger and deeper screen.
However, what is gained in processing power is somewhat offset by hardware reductions. The first-generation HomePod has 7 speakers and 6 microphones, while the second generation has 5 speakers and 4 microphones. These changes are aimed at maintaining sound quality.
Key Similarities:
Both HomePod models support HomeKit for controlling smart home accessories and feature AirPlay and AirPlay 2 for streaming content from Apple devices. Users can create stereo pairs with either two HomePods (first generation) or two HomePods 2, but pairing across generations is not supported.
Considerations:
- Price: Due to the discontinuation of the first-generation HomePod, it can be found at significantly lower prices, ranging from 170 to 200 euros (when buying second-hand). In contrast, the HomePod 2 has a current retail price of 349 euros. The first-generation HomePod represents substantial savings, making it an attractive option for those on a budget.
- Primary Use: If the primary purpose of your smart speaker is for high-quality music listening, a second-hand first-generation HomePod will more than suffice. The sound quality of the initial model is impressive.
- Connected Ecosystem: If you prioritize a connected ecosystem, compatibility with a wide range of Apple accessories, and future-proofing your setup, the second-generation HomePod is a more suitable choice.
In conclusion, your decision between the first-generation HomePod and the HomePod 2 depends on your intended use and budget. If you seek a secondary music device with outstanding audio quality, a second-hand first-generation HomePod is a cost-effective choice. However, if you value a connected ecosystem and future accessory compatibility, the second-generation HomePod is the way to go. Ultimately, the choice is yours, and it should align with your specific needs and preferences.